Alcatel Idol S
$299
Alcatel Idol S vs Samsung Galaxy A17 8GB
Samsung Galaxy A17 8GB
$225
| Idol S | Galaxy A17 8GB | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | USD 299 | USD 225 |
| Battery | 2000 mAh | 5000 mAh |
| Charging (W) | 5 | 25 |
| RAM | 1 GB | 8 GB |
| Storage | 4 GB | 256 GB |
| Chipset | Qualcomm Snapdragon 400 MSM8930 | MediaTek Helio G99 |
| Display | 4.7" • IPS LCD • 60Hz | 6.7" • Super AMOLED • 90Hz |
| Main Camera | 8MP | 50MP |
| Front Camera | 1.3MP | 13MP |
| OS | Android 4.2 Jelly Bean | Android 15 |
Detailed comparison will load when you open this tab.
Key Differences
Only the differences that meaningfully separate these phones.
Price
USD 74 cheaper
Galaxy A17 8GBUSD 225
vsIdol SUSD 299
RAM
8× more RAM
Galaxy A17 8GB8 GB RAM
vsIdol S1 GB RAM
Storage
64× more storage
Galaxy A17 8GB256 GB
vsIdol S4 GB
Battery
150% larger battery
Galaxy A17 8GB5,000 mAh
vsIdol S2,000 mAh
Charging
20 W faster wired charging
Galaxy A17 8GB25 W wired
vsIdol S5 W wired
Performance
Different chipsets
Idol SQualcomm Snapdragon 400 MSM8930
vsGalaxy A17 8GBMediaTek Helio G99
Display
Larger90Hz
Galaxy A17 8GB6.7″ · 90Hz
vsIdol S4.7″ · 60Hz
Best For
Where each phone stands out based on this comparison.
Best if you want
More hardwareSamsung Galaxy A17 8GB
Much lower purchase priceUSD 225
More RAM and storage8 GB RAM · 256 GB
Larger battery5,000 mAh
Faster wired charging25 W wired
What CompareTab says about Alcatel Idol S vs Samsung Galaxy A17 8GB
Samsung Galaxy A17 8GB has clear advantages in memory, battery capacity and display refresh rate over Idol S, with 8 GB of RAM versus 1 GB, 256 GB of storage versus 4 GB, a 5000 mAh battery versus 2000 mAh, and a 90 Hz display instead of 60 Hz. It also adds a higher-resolution rear camera (50 MP versus 8 MP), a higher-resolution front camera (13 MP versus 1.3 MP), optical image stabilization on the main camera, and 25W charging. Alcatel Idol S, however, is lighter at 110 g versus 192 g. The main trade-off is Galaxy A17 8GB’s extra RAM, storage, faster charging, battery capacity, and smoother display versus Idol S’s lighter build.
